When a difficult conversation becomes an HR issue
Most workplace problems start as a quiet word, and many are solved that way. The skill is noticing when an informal chat is no longer enough and a more formal step is needed.
Start informal where you can
A direct, respectful conversation often resolves an issue before it grows. Be specific about what you have noticed, listen to the response and agree what happens next. Keep a brief note even for informal chats.
Watch for the signs it needs to be formal
Some signals suggest an informal approach has run its course.
- The same problem keeps returning after being raised.
- The issue is serious, such as safety or possible misconduct.
- Someone has made an allegation about another person.
- There may be a discrimination or wellbeing dimension.
Make the shift carefully
Moving from informal to formal changes things for the employee, so be clear about why and what the process will involve. A fair, well explained step is easier to accept than one that appears to come from nowhere.
Keep it fair and proportionate
Formal does not mean heavy handed. Match the process to the issue, follow a fair procedure and keep good records. The goal is to resolve the problem properly, not to punish.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Going formal too early for a minor issue.
- Leaving a serious issue informal for too long.
- Switching to a formal process with no explanation.
- Keeping no record of the earlier conversations.
When to get HR support
Managers can handle many conversations themselves. Get advice when the situation tips into higher risk territory.
- An allegation has been made about someone.
- The issue involves possible discrimination or harassment.
- Informal steps have not worked.
- You are unsure whether to formalise it.
Want your managers to handle situations like this with more confidence? See our HR training.
Last reviewed: 19 June 2026.
This article is general guidance for employers. It is not a substitute for tailored HR or legal advice for your particular situation.
An issue that needs handling?
Get advice on the right next step.
Common questions
Yes, a brief note of what was discussed and agreed is sensible even for informal conversations. It helps everyone remember and supports a fair process if things escalate.
Be honest and clear. Explain what has led to the step, what the process involves and what their rights are. People cope better with a process they understand.
An informal conversation is not a disciplinary, but if the issue is serious or continues, it can lead to one. Be clear with the person about which stage you are at.
Want advice on your situation?
Tell me what is happening and I will suggest the most suitable next step.
Tell me what’s happening →